Paxos lecture (Raft user study)

What people said

cljacoby · 2024-02 · Strong recommendation

I recently took a Distributed Systems course, and I also thought it was very interesting and unexpected how in the most basic form of Paxos, there is no concept of node roles or hierarchy like leader/follower, master/replica, etc. The base case is that all nodes have the same replicated log, and are "writers" capable of initiating changes to the log. This youtube video was particularly helpful in learning about consensus algorithms, specifically Paxos/MultiPaxos: [VIDEO] John Ousterhout (author of Raft) walks through Paxos/MultiPaxos as outlined by Leslie Lamport, and then talks about a series of optimizations to improve performance. One key optimization is transitioning from performing consensus on a single log-slot proposal, to the entire log-slot altogether, which mitigates failed consensus rounds, and is where concepts like leader nodes emerge. If your familiar with Raft and Paxos, while listening to these optimization applied to MultiPaxos, you can kind of notice it to begin to resemble Raft. The course I took was through Georgia Tech, but was largely based around a framework developed at the University of Washington called dslabs: [LINK] [LINK] It was super informative for my learning about the foundations of distributed systems, namely consensus algorithms. I'd highly recommend it for anyone interested in learning more. Although fair warning, the programming assignments were quite difficult and time consuming.

Read the original HN comment ↗

krat0sprakhar · 2014-10 · Strong recommendation

One of the most lucid explanations of the Raft Consensus Algorithm that I've ever seen is the one in John Ousterhout and Diego Ongaro's Raft User Study[0]. The 2 videos do an excellent job of explaining both the Paxos and Raft algorithms and the key differences between them. John's narration is extremely clear and the slides are very informative. Definitely recommended! Raft is a consensus algorithm designed to be easier to understand than Paxos. To measure Raft's understandability, we conducted an experimental study using CS students at two universities. We recorded a video lecture of Raft and another of Paxos, and created corresponding quizzes. This page makes our materials available for anyone interested. We think these are valuable resources for anyone learning consensus (whether Raft or Paxos or both). [0] - [LINK] Raft Video - [LINK] Paxos Video - [VIDEO]

Read the original HN comment ↗

ignoramous · 2021-07 · Recommendation

Raft is very similar to Multi-Paxos. These Raft and Paxos user studies comparing the "understandability" of the two protocols might be helpful: [VIDEO] (Paxos), [LINK] (Raft). See also, comparison of various "Paxos" implementations: [LINK]

Read the original HN comment ↗